Rutherford, CA - Auberge Du Soleil

For our anniversary this year we went to Auberge du Soleil. The price of Aubergine, the restaurant at L'Auberge Carmel, was pretty intense so we thought we would take it "easy" this year. First though, a little background on Aubergine and how I used it to rate Auberge du Soleil. I picked Aubergine last year based on it being in the Relais & Châteaux family. It didn't have a Michelin Star. Michelin Stars have nothing to do with restaurants I enjoy, and I hope to never become one of those snobs who can only eat or talk about Michelin Stars. It only came up because following our dinner, they mentioned that they are trying to get a Michelin Star. We were surprised that they didn't have one. It was, hands down, one of the best meals we had ever enjoyed. The presentation was on point, and the food was fantastic. Carmel is the perfect location for fresh seafood, and the chef definitely uses it to his advantage. That said, in choosing Auberge du Soleil this year, was based on other reviews and that it was in the same Relais & Châteaux family. The fact that it does have a Michelin Star had no part in the decision.

But then, the fact that it does have a star made it the more disappointing that it was not at the level of Aubergine. It was really the little things that took the meal down for me. Service felt perfunctory at Auberge, whereas Aubergine was very friendly and they anticipated what we needed. Crumbs were ignored between courses while even Ruth's Chris Steak House tends to them when they see them. When serving our last course, they assumed we wouldn't want the wine pairing because "most people don't want it." I found the comment strange. Overlooking the fact that the wine pairings weren't done anywhere near as well as Aubergine, and that the pours were too much for a tasting (I know, now I'm complaining about too much wine #firstworldproblems), why would you just assume that people don't want something that they paid for? Furthermore, I really need to add that Semillon with foie gras really didn't work for me. It was so sweet.

Do I have nice things to say about Auberge du Soleil? I do. I still enjoyed dinner. Dining companions affect my take on food and I was with good company. The view was nice and relaxing. There were a few courses that really worked well for me, and I think would have been better had I not gotten the wine pairing. Perhaps if I had skipped the wine pairing and just ordered the chef's tasting, I would have left with a better taste of the food. The squab, scallop, and dessert were my favorites. My suggestion if you want to give it a try would be to skip the wine pairing and order the courses you like from their regular menu. 

The Chef's Offerings change based on whatever is freshest and is six courses ($150 for the Chef's Tasting, add on $94 for the wine pairing).
The view from the deck.
French butter with salt. 
Complimentary amuse bouche - parsnip gazpacho with some bacon.
Course #1: Day boat scallop with glazed pork belly, black trumpets, grilled cabbage,Thai broth, and tapioca pearls. This was paired with a 2010 Vincent Girardin"Les Vermots Dessus" Chardonnay - Savigny-les-Beaune Blanc from Burgundy-France.

The tapioca pearls were trying a bit too hard, in my humble opinion, but the scallop was good, nonetheless.
Course #2: Foie gras torchon with roasted beets, bee pollen, and pistachios. This was paired with a 2011 Chateau Grand-Maison "Cufee du Chateau" Semillon - Sauvignon Blanc from Monbazillac-France.

I liked this course a lot. At this point though, I regretted getting the wine pairing.
Course #3: Veal Sweetbreads with morel mushrooms, fava beans, roasted shallots, ramps, and sherry. Paired with a 2012 DuMol - Pinot Noir from the Russian River Valley.
Sea salts for the entree: salt from the UK and Himalayan pink salt.
Our cutlery.
Cute little bee.
Course #4: Paine Farm Squab with lentil du puy, foie gras, frisee, and bacon. Paired with a 2012 Clos du Mont Olivet - Chateauneuf-du-Pape from Rhone, France.

Cooked medium rare, the squab was pretty good.
Course #5: Prime beef Pave with asparagus, bacon spatzle, tarragon, and mustard vinaigrette. Paired with a 2012 Araujo "Altagracia" - Cabernet Sauvignon from the Napa Valley.

The steak tasted much better after utilizing the accompanying salt. 
Final course/dessert of Honey poached apples with yuzu mochi, Greek yogurt, Granny Smith Apple sorbet. Paired with a 2010 Domaine des Baumard - Chenin Blanc from Loire, France.

This was probably my favorite course. The sorbet was refreshing and light. The yuzu mochi was citrusy and provided a good contrast to the crumble and yogurt.

Address:
180 Rutherford Hill Road
Rutherford, CA 94573

Reservations recommended.

Hours:
Mon-Sun 7am-9:30pm
(different times for breakfast, lunch, and dinner)

Comments

Post a Comment

I would love to hear from you!

Popular posts from this blog

[Kaohsiung, Taiwan] - 桦達奶茶 Huada Milk Tea (Original Location Only)

Image
If you are a milk tea fan, this is a must go spot. It's one of the oldest tea milk tea shops in Southern Taiwan, and from the looks of it, do everything the same as they always have. This post is only about the original location. They have many other locations around the island, but this was the first. I'm told the other locations aren't that great and some people even told me not to try it. But, I like trying the originals, and I have loved milk tea since the summer of 1992 so no harm in throwing down 30NT for one, right? When I mentioned to the local milk tea shop owner that I was going to Kaohsiung, he said I have to try Huada also, so that was definitely good enough for me! Located close to the Yangchengpu KMRT station and in a smaller road, remember to watch out for those scooters! They have a good variety of drinks, but I ordered the original milk tea. They shake it with ice so it's cold, but probably not cold enough for American standards. This milk tea is d
Read more

[Kaohsiung, Taiwan] - 查理布朗咖啡店 | Charlie Brown Café Taiwan

Image
I have been a huge fan of Snoopy for as long as I can remember (which is a long, long time). Having already been to one of the Charlie Brown Cafes in Hong Kong, I figured why not also go to the one in Kaohsiung? If you want to go, it's pretty easy. Kaohsiung has an MRT system like the one in Taipei. Take the red line to the Hanshin Arena KMRT stop and walk up Baoi Road 2nd to Baoi Road 3rd. You should see the Hanshin department store on the left. Just walk a few blocks and you'll see the Charlie Brown Cafe on the left side of the road (same side as the department store) with the cross street of Zhizhen Road. It's pretty hard to miss! If you're lucky, it's not too busy and Snoopy is available to join you for some afternoon coffee, tea, sparkly drinks, and/or snacks. Lemon mix blue curacao/檸檬藍柑氣泡飲 When I went to pay at the counter, I saw that there were these super cute waffles in the shape of Snoopy, Charlie Brown, and Woodstock. How often
Read more

[Daly City, CA] - Noodle in a Haystack

Image
Noodle in a Haystack is a ramen pop-up that I have been following for about a year now. Through following them, I learned that they had been working on their yuzu shio ramen for a few years now, and that they started making their own ramen because the local selection wasn't great , especially after having gotten used to the ramen in Japan (I was pretty excited to know that I wasn't alone in this assessment, or that others have suffered from culture shock moving back to the States!). Before I went to Japan and had real  ramen, I wasn't that picky. After having Ichiran and a few other random places, I just wasn't able to eat ramen anywhere. Santouka became the only place that I would go to, but their ramen is only tonkotsu. I personally prefer miso ramen, so the tonkotsu is too heavy for me to enjoy frequently. At first, I wasn't sure about going to Noodle in a Haystack because it looked like it was $50 for ramen. Let me explain why it's more than just ramen,
Read more